Originally Posted On: https://www.jscreen.org/blog/7-myths-about-hereditary-cancer-screening
7 Myths About Hereditary Cancer Screening
When it comes to your health, knowledge truly is power. Hereditary cancer screening provides valuable information about your genetic risk factors, empowering you to make informed decisions about your health journey. Despite the clear benefits of genetic testing, many misconceptions may prevent individuals from accessing this potentially life-saving resource.
Myth #1: “Genetic testing won’t help me because I can’t change my genes.”
FACT: While it’s true you cannot change your genetic makeup, knowing about inherited gene mutations that increase cancer risk allows you to take proactive steps to reduce that risk or detect cancer at its earliest, most treatable stage.
If genetic testing reveals an increased risk of developing certain types of cancer, you can work with your healthcare provider to develop a personalized risk-reduction plan.
This might include:
- Enhanced screening protocols starting at a younger age
- More frequent screening to monitor changes closely
- Risk-reducing medications
- Preventive surgeries in some high-risk cases
- Lifestyle modifications that may lower risk factors
For example, individuals with BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene mutations have an increased risk of developing breast and ovarian cancer. Knowing about this risk allows for earlier and more frequent breast imaging, potentially catching cancer at a more treatable stage. It may also inform decisions about risk-reducing surgeries that can significantly decrease cancer risk.
Myth #2: “Cancer screening technologies cause more harm than good.”
FACT: Modern screening technologies are safe, and the benefits of early detection far outweigh any minimal risks associated with the screening procedures.
Let’s address some common concerns:
Mammograms: While mammograms do involve a small amount of radiation, the dose is very low, and the benefit of early breast cancer detection far outweighs this minimal exposure. Digital mammography has further reduced radiation exposure while improving image quality.
MRI Screening: Breast MRIs may be recommended for high-risk individuals. These use magnetic fields rather than radiation and pose no radiation risk.
Sample collection: Genetic testing typically requires only a small saliva sample, with virtually no physical risk to the patient.
The actual harm comes from undetected cancers that could have been found through appropriate screening measures. For individuals with inherited cancer risk, consistent screening according to medical guidelines is especially important.
Myth #3: “If no one in my family has had cancer, I don’t need genetic testing.”
FACT: While family medical history is essential, it doesn’t tell the complete story about your cancer risk.
Some reasons why genetic testing might be beneficial even without a family history of cancer:
- Individuals of Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry are at a baseline risk of 1 in 40 to carry specific mutation in BRCA1 and BRCA2, regardless of family history
- Some genetic mutations can be present without causing cancer in previous generations (reduced penetrance)
- Limited family size or predominantly male relatives might mask hereditary breast or ovarian cancer risk
- Adoption or unknown family history scenarios
- Rarely, genetic mutations can occur spontaneously
- Family members might have had cancer but at an older age, or the information wasn’t shared
Additionally, some types of cancer have strong genetic links that benefit from testing even without a family history. For instance, approximately 20-25% of women with ovarian cancer have a hereditary predisposition, regardless of family history.
Myth #4: “Genetic testing is expensive and not covered by insurance.”
FACT: Many insurance plans now cover genetic testing for hereditary cancer when medically indicated, and there are multiple options for affordable testing regardless of insurance status.
The landscape of genetic testing has changed dramatically over the past decade. Testing costs have decreased significantly, and insurance coverage has expanded.
Key points to know:
- Most insurance plans cover genetic testing for individuals with specific personal or family history criteria.
- The Affordable Care Act requires insurance coverage for genetic counseling and BRCA testing for women whose family history suggests increased risk.
- Many testing companies offer financial assistance programs.
- Non-profit organizations often provide resources for reduced-cost testing.
- Panel tests that examine multiple genes at once have become more affordable and accessible.
At jscreen, we are committed to ensure accessibility by offering affordable screening options, removing financial barriers to accessing crucial genetic information.
Myth #5: “Only women need to worry about hereditary cancer risk.”
FACT: Men can also carry and pass on genetic mutations that increase cancer risk, and some hereditary cancer syndromes directly increase men’s risk of certain cancers.
While we often associate hereditary cancer screening with conditions like breast and ovarian cancer, genetic testing is equally important for men:
- Men with BRCA mutations have increased risk for male breast cancer, prostate cancer, pancreatic cancer, and melanoma
- Lynch syndrome, for example, increases colon cancer risk and risk of other GI cancers regardless of gender
- Men can pass hereditary cancer gene mutations to their children
- A family history of cancer on the paternal side is just as significant as on the maternal side
Understanding that cancer-risk genes can be inherited from either parent helps ensure that important family history isn’t overlooked when assessing risk.
Myth #6: “If I test positive for a cancer gene mutation, I will develop cancer.”
FACT: Testing positive for a genetic mutation indicates increased risk, not certainty. Many people with gene mutations never develop cancer, especially with proper monitoring and risk-reduction strategies.
A positive genetic test result means you have inherited a specific gene mutation that increases your cancer risk compared to the general population.
However:
- Gene mutations have varying levels of “penetrance” (likelihood of causing disease)
- Environmental factors and lifestyle choices still play significant roles
- Risk-reducing strategies can significantly lower cancer likelihood
- Regular screening often allows for early detection when treatment is most successful
Knowing your genetic status empowers you to work with healthcare providers on personalized screening and prevention plans tailored to your risk profile.
Myth #7: “I’m too young to worry about cancer screening.”
FACT: For individuals with hereditary cancer syndromes, screening often needs to begin at a younger age than general population guidelines recommend.
When there’s an inherited increased risk of developing cancer, the recommended age to begin screening is typically:
- 5-10 years before the earliest age of cancer diagnosis in the family, or
- At the age specified in medical guidelines for that particular genetic syndrome, whichever is sooner
For example, while routine mammograms typically begin at age 40-50 for average-risk women, those with BRCA mutations or other high-risk factors may start as early as age 25. Similarly, colonoscopy screening might begin in the 20s for individuals with Lynch syndrome rather than at age 45 for average-risk individuals.
Early and consistent screening is critical in the setting of high cancer risk, as hereditary cancers sometimes develop at younger ages than sporadic cancers.
Why Consistent Screening Matters for High-Risk Individuals
Consistent screening is not just a recommendation for those with increased genetic risk—it’s an essential part of a comprehensive health strategy.
Here’s why:
Monitoring Changes: Regular screening allows healthcare providers to track subtle changes that might indicate early disease development. For those with hereditary cancer predisposition, these changes can be more significant and may occur at a faster rate than in the general population.
Early Detection: Consistent screening significantly increases the chances of detecting cancer at its earliest, most treatable stage. When breast cancer is detected early, the 5-year survival rate is greater than 90%. Similar improvements in outcomes are seen with early detection of colon cancer, ovarian cancer, and other hereditary cancer types.
Personalized Intervals: Screening intervals are typically shorter for high-risk individuals to ensure any developing cancer is caught promptly. For example, someone with Lynch syndrome may need colonoscopies every 1-2 years rather than every 10 years as recommended for individuals of average risk.
Peace of Mind: Regular screening provides reassurance during the intervals between tests. Knowing you’re following the recommended protocols explicitly designed for your risk level can significantly reduce anxiety about cancer risk.
Adaptation to New Technologies: Staying in regular contact with healthcare providers ensures you benefit from advances in screening technologies as they become available. Cancer screening constantly evolves, with more sensitive and specific tests being developed regularly.
Taking the Next Step
Understanding your hereditary cancer risk through genetic testing provides valuable information that can guide critical health decisions for you and your family. Genetic counseling—both before and after testing—helps ensure you understand the implications of your results and have support in navigating the next steps.
Remember that hereditary cancer screening is not about finding problems but finding solutions and creating personalized health plans based on your unique genetic profile.
What to Expect from the Screening Process
If you decide to pursue hereditary cancer screening, here’s what you can generally expect:
- Sample collection: You’ll provide a simple saliva sample. This quick, painless process can often be done during a consultation visit or from home.
- Laboratory analysis: Your sample will be analyzed for genetic mutations associated with increased cancer risk. This typically takes about 2-3 weeks.
- Results and counseling: You’ll meet with a genetic counselor or healthcare provider to review your results and discuss their implications for your health management plan.
If you have questions about hereditary cancer screening or want to learn if testing is proper for you, speak with your healthcare provider or contact a genetic counselor. Taking a proactive approach to understanding your cancer risk is a decisive step toward protecting your health.